Dessert Menu Options

*Pump House Catering has a wonderful cake baker for your convenience upon request and cupcakes too!

  • Vanilla ice cream plain or with chocolate sauce or rainbow sherbet
  • Individual house cupcakes -- strawberry, vanilla and chocolate
  • Cookies, Brownies or cookie bars
  • Chocolate Mousse
  • New York style cheesecake with three assorted toppings
  • Assorted fruit parfaits
  • Apple or pumpkin pie (ice cream added for additional cost)
  • Chocolate cake, carrot cake or coconut cake
  • Warm chocolate fudge fondue bar with assorted dippers
  • Ice cream sundae bar
  • Turtle cheesecake
  • Homemade Black Forest Torte or strawberry shortcake
  • Assortment of gourmet cheesecakes
  • Hot apple dumpling with scoop of vanilla ice cream
  • Strawberries Romanoff
  • Triple chocolate fudge cake
  • Hot skillet cobblers (serves 2-4 each) served with vanilla ice cream

Customized menus, types of service and quotes are available upon request.  We do our best to work within your budget! Please contact us for more information.